St Mary’s Island: A chequered past

St Mary's Island at low tide.  Image by Jim Blakeley.
St Mary’s Island at low tide. Image by Jim Blakeley.

Originally named Bates Island after Thomas Bates who owned it during the reign of Queen Elizabeth 1, St Mary’s Island is a quaint and peaceful little island situated off the North East Coast of England, between Whitley Bay and Seaton Sluice. Neatly sitting opposite Curry’s point on the mainland, the island is accessible at low tide by causeway. Whilst a light has shone in some capacity on the island for centuries, the most prominent feature and tourist attraction is it’s lighthouse which was built in 1898, and decommissioned and turned into a visitor centre in 1984.

Back in the medieval days there was a chapel on the island, and right next to the chapel was a burial ground where the monks were buried. Unfortunately all traces of the chapel were destroyed when the lighthouse was built.

It’s difficult to imagine when you visit it now that such a small and tranquil little island could have such a dark and chequered history, however in it’s time the island has suffered from a plague of locusts, and is also the setting of a horrific and brutal murder; namely that of Anthony Mitchell, a local customs officer who was slain brutally by smugglers who in the year 1722 had been illegally hovering off the North East coast line, his body dumped in what became known as smugglers creek on the north of the island; the creek still being visible to visitors to the island today.

Smugglers by John Atkinson.  Public domain via Wikimedia.
Smugglers by John Atkinson. Public domain via Wikimedia.

Then just a few years later in the year 1739, Michael Curry, a local glassworker, was found guilty of the murder of the landlord of the inn at Old Hartley. He was duly hanged for his crime in Newcastle, and as was customary in those days his body was hung on a gibbet in sight of his crime, at the spot which is now known as Curry’s point.

In 1799 a boat load of Russian Soldiers on their way to fight in the Napoleonic wars, were struck down with cholera and the island was used to quarantine them.

Then later, in the nineteenth century, a local couple obtained permission from the landlord Lord Hastings to open a public house on the island. The pub was known locally as the Square and Compass, and the family lived there peacefully doing a roaring trade for decades, until a dispute over their drunken customers brawling on neighbouring land, resulted in the somewhat ungainly eviction of the family and their pigs from the island that they loved.

St Mary’s island and it’s dark history features heavily in my novel Granny Irene’s Guide to the Afterlife, Revenge.

St Mary's Island with tide coming in.  Image by Jim Blakeley.
St Mary’s Island with tide coming in. Image by Jim Blakeley.

Sources

En.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_Mary’s_Island,_Tyne_and_Wear
St Mary’s Lighthouse | North Tyneside Council
northeasthistorytour.blogspot.com/…/stmarys-island-lighthouse-nz35375

10 responses to “St Mary’s Island…”

  1. Ingrid, thank you for a really interesting post, so much history for such a tiny island! I look forward to reading your next post.

  2. Author Ingrid Hall avatar
    Author Ingrid Hall

    Reblogged this on and commented:
    check out the article on St Mary’s Island, which features in my novel ,that I have written for haunted palace blog.

  3. Author Ingrid Hall avatar
    Author Ingrid Hall

    I will gladly write some more posts for you – watch this space!!

  4. I’m guessing that, unlike in your novel, there are no caves on the island…

  5. Author Ingrid Hall avatar
    Author Ingrid Hall

    Hi Steve, I don’t think there are any actual caves on the island, certainly none that are big enough or accessible enough to the public (If anyone out there knows otherwise please feel free to correct me because I would love to have a poke around them!!) However Smugglers Creek is real. That is the alleyway in the rocks that I use in the novel with Anthony’s cave at the end of it. The real life smugglers made use of the caves a bit further along the coast at Cullercoats. Hope that answers your question!!

    1. It does indeed! Thanks for the clarification.

  6. That is really fascinating – having visited St Mary’s island many times I had no idea whether there were caves there or not!

  7. Hi, I am not entirely sure what weapon was used. I would love to hear the recording! Would you be able to send a copy to ingrid@luv2write.net please? Best Wishes, Ingrid

  8. Hi, having done a little research I can tell you that Robert Shervill, the murder victim, on his death bed gave an account of how Michael Curry attacked him in the Three Horseshoes, on the night of 11 January 1738/9. He awoke in bed to find Curry on top of him beating him with his hands and knees before pulling out Shervill’s own razor and cutting a four inch gash in his throat. The Gallows Tree by Barry Redfern has a good account of the murder.

  9. Wow, that’s really interesting! I’m just coming back to this comment now. I’ll send you the email of the recording shortly and I’ll also check out your blog. Feel free to use the recording wherever you like 🙂

Leave a Reply to Author Ingrid HallCancel reply

Trending

Discover more from The Haunted Palace Blog

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading